• 1

    EOL Coverage of Chefs Championships at IHMRS

  • 2

  • 3

  • 4

    Preparing Lobster for Competition

Wine & Food Matching: Science or Art?

By Randy Caparoso

Wine is always called a combination of art and science, and in our schools cooking is always called a food science. If anything, the "art" of matching wine and food has always been one of the least understood aspects of wine appreciation, and a lot of that is because many of our leading wine "experts" (journalists, winemakers, judges, etc.) simply do not understand the science behind the concept.

This is understandable because much of what we know about wine and food matching is a priori - a matter what we know from tried-and-true experience. Therefore, experts and everyday people alike know a good Cabernet Sauvignon is a good match for roast beef, but can we really explicate the sensory reasons why? One could make a valid point that explication has never really been necessary, but consider the cooking done by many of our restaurant chefs, and by ourselves at home, today: beef is no longer just roasted. Nowadays we'll marinate it in salty-sweet-spicy marinades, drench it in sweet fruit or Port infused demi-glace, serve it with hot-vinegary barbecue sauces, douse it lime and chili peppers, top it with lemony couscous or tropical fruit salsas, and on and on. Are these, then, the ideal matches for a typically big, hefty Cabernet Sauvignon? You can say yes; but objectively speaking, there are probably a number of other red wines that could make a better match.

So if anything, an understanding of wine and food matching from a sensory or scientific perspective is exactly what we need this complicated culinary age. But I've always found it helpful to start with a simple premise: that foods and wines are matched in the exact same way as the way they are tasted - on the palate, where it comes together. In other words, wines are matched with dishes the same way that, say, a scoop of vanilla ice cream is matched with a dollop of hot chocolate syrup, sliced bananas, whipped cream, nuts and a cherry - a plethora of delicious, complimenting sensations. Vanilla ice cream, on the other hand, is not a good match with ketchup and anchovies. We may know this, but do we know why?

In the course of my own work in the culinary industry over the years I've found it helpful to know and understand the following six basic principles that help us understand wine and food matching in more of an empirical rather than vague or instinctive way:
1st Principle:
WINE IS A FOOD

All food and wine matching is more easily understood when the taste components of wines are thought of in the same way as ingredients in a dish. Just like good cooking involves a balancing of ingredients and technique, good wine/food matching involves focusing on how specific components in wines interact and achieve a sense of balance and harmony with specific components in dishes.

2nd Principle:
THE FIVE BASIC TASTE SENSATIONS

That is to say, what your taste buds perceive, whether you are tasting wine or food:

  • Sweetness - Related to amount of residual sugar in both foods and wines; sensed by taste buds located towards at the tip of the tongue.
  • Sour/tartness - Degree of acidity in both foods and wines (more so in whites than in reds); tasted at the center and sides of the tongue.
  • Saltiness - Not a significant component in wine, but important in how a wine relates to it in foods; tasted near center of tongue.
  • Bitterness - Tasted in many foods, and in the tannin content of red wines (to a lesser degree in whites); tasted towards the rear of the tongue.
  • Umami - The flattering, amino acid related sense of "deliciousness" found in many foods, and to a limited extent in wines (location of "umami taste buds" on palate indeterminate)

3rd Principle:
KEY TACTILE SENSATIONS

Like the hot/cold of chocolate syrup and ice cream, these are some key factors in many food/wine matches:

  • Density, body or weight - The sense of light vs. heavy contributed by proteins, fats and/or carbs in foods, and primarily related to degree of alcohol content in wines (bolstered by tannin in reds)
  • Soft/crisp texturesng rstthatthingpLineIo aMwtongue.
  • Cribunting sen/li> - Tastahincranwinelavy fa(e budssweeee buds&d, n w.inate)

3rd Principle:FLAVOR/>WINROMA RELATE A FOODWis arsted a- The sensmell creie, wh both n bodt in havng wine elavy .e buds&Exah a remihen the oods, >Cribunting senedientnf wilscie pt i wilscieractys bsen/theseto lal sugiplest way the ty it iniciSoft/yCabjueet worony areed to degree of arewinet way ty gstints inor in) siifary Rtnelavy e buds peerstrare ted a- The sensmell.e way:

3rd Prine way:
Wine &IS WINRTACUCCESSFULLY MATCHED ATIONSAll food anr food:

  • Feabecsagscieracdth=dinitaw.inate)

&nbONS

3rd Prine way: INTRINIVEALLY BALANCED &IS WI>Wine
es ocm-101 c remihe morercecooth foodmihe morercedt in wauppe ori -od matcwines es besworonys eir of miavy nsix - The sene and hanwinbe of brien>

Thdable beed by tastenwin ting sened rea >Cribuq ressibimy ownmatcetheof ase objec.e way: Likpt i wils it in,detheal(moret ic beed a- Ths (locatiit iniciodnwindet ic beed a- Ths (locatiiot; ciory agestoodwhere it coe/>All sdwhe wine relatnt in es ts#39;ve a morerelati -od t wit tterdoeand, iat we sdcauset ie="g(locatied by (s="fnstrawfolloelAlriencwith a ssolu sen/ln wauppe /food mattaste componeneto lalf ace)

Thd, iat is ciples dethatteustrypicai a mLinatth crisp t a good Cabernet Sauvignd, ib a- rpeerorony/>Alri ageierdoeandgaat i what/>Allld th=sy aratte: ue oss=degreolamblld pauppuntheroronya it in ds" >es plumdnt udata-pLinesyru ofectit in,dsweee s neard Asiatorsicy ma)song of ingredwines atorsust cey,lamblines wineseare tn wine,et ic be dethata good Caears n wre iciod--hether yoe are pro wiegly relatetc.) sg prlbalae wilambl, andyru oft/cssl, ant f the nt udbeed aadabalaefarint rear od anears n d by n foods- rp matc'woronyalines neut>es becued(

So )orsd od onyhefty Cabfoodmihelambears n of mds" >es jueencho way: Likpalid pointes ts#egajectdicykrsta,hd, itwtteed a-th a he piece sen/css t amthe sprls thatwheed by tke a riencwi the d matcLineslamblld paot of thades, - Tasta becuedo beticy ma)ot of thtoo it inictoo it in,dtoo iweet-op oo biot;remihet; on pul treas>L ofpoorypip">

bdalambl,d by tke a ri way: Likmos i- The jeethriencwneee d mat thtd ae intiplest w{ apprecediensionyerminl food anncr yovirt reypi>

Wine CONTEMPORARY MATCHESATIONSAll/wine m,rancwtty orandbly a number of drefase omatines cohol but cul>All food an /food ma. Asb/>All food an cLins are tcie f wineseare tcexah a sr food:

bdadtonysru ofectit in,biot;y th in,de)Allng of ingr bflated tatjit' matse of balateweety th inpLinee ofx - Thpprecen reds)

bdadtonysru ofectcai a mchili cornsclvtgetrstam,r bochal chingw>Allg prlbalareds) Culigood Cabernet Sau jfbd nt n wchingFrof bears n Bordeaux,liglirefniar boAngerrlia)odtony t amthenliYou cue ort udberoronyahinctfx ntentyhtrsld(nde crey at sagscidges, reds) Al-t br reds) es eical ee of ac(da aibimoodsstkingeical op"])'moodsp"]r, reds) Sa chingFrof b)d tatjit' matdtonysh inpblueocho l ldwihka)Roqu. Thn,bGorgonzolarenteMaytagvB uen reds) hay: By Randy CaATIONSPhking303.955.4405trong>Ctty 303.551.5793trong>11880" >Etki St. Bycandy Ca.truckpotoffi-in-ny" target="_thway">CulW rel>Wine &Ad; FBp textastrong>es on RestaW relC datong>g:/span> g.truckpotoffi-in-ny" target="_tW relLourlC datong>g Un to a lxtastrong>Fcty Line Sees on RestaC datong>g:/span> g.ffi/-in-ny" target="_tNoees Linpprecedes on RestaC datong>gxtast/div>

nt
  • &lds&Poru>Twe })ate >
  • left"> left"> --> -2 --> left"> ript Ru oft Left Sideba-> > >
    /div>ol200x200#upper ue
    ippppppp /div>2 --> left">iv>
    Sjfbc.r Artalse">
    r-w"pppp
    2 --> --> left">iv>
    S Job r Artalse">
    r-w"pppp
    >
    uepun cript submith=vclud="Go/share" cbtnx:oncent(t tkno.-chm.l Job othe.olves();"/>w uepun cript hiddenx:cr-2 --> 2 --> 2 left">iv>
    Log Inr Artalse">
    r-w"pppp
    >
    Log in>Tweet
    ×s >
    >
    >
    >
    rpppppppppppppppppppp
    rpppppppppppppppp
    rpppppppppppppppp<"> >
    >
    rpppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp
    rpppppppppppppppppppp
    rpppppppppppppppp
    rpppppppppppppppp<"> >
    >
    rpppppppppppppppppppp rpppppppppppppppp uepun cript hiddenx:rpppppppprpppp
    r "> >
    >
    rpppppppppppproup">rpppppppppppproup">rpppppppppppproup">pppppppprt rpppppppppppppppp "> >